| Team |
W-L-T |
| Cal State East Bay |
22-14-0 |
| Chapman University |
35-3-0 |
| University of Dallas |
23-17-0 |
| Finlandia University |
3-12-0 |
| Lancaster Bible College |
12-18-0 |
| Maine-Presque Isle |
5-17-0 |
| Nebraska Wesleyan |
21-20-0 |
| Newbury College |
4-24-0 |
| St. Joseph's College (NY) |
2-16-0 |
| Southern Vermont |
7-26-0 |
|
| Team |
W-L-T |
| Cal State East Bay |
11-23-0 |
| Chapman University |
27-9-0 |
| University of Dallas |
13-17-0 |
| Finlandia University |
10-12-0 |
| Green Mountain College |
15-16-0 |
| Maine-Presque Isle |
3-15-0 |
| Mitchell College |
13-19-0 |
| Nebraska Wesleyan |
22-16-0 |
| Newbury College |
13-24-0 |
| St. Joseph's College (NY) |
10-21-0 |
| College of St. Elizabeth |
13-16-0 |
| Southern Vermont |
0-24-0 |
|
